Ethical and Social Impact Assessment

Imagine you’re designing a new AI tool. Before you start coding, you need to answer these questions:

• Data Considerations:

  • What type of data will you use?
  • Who owns the data and where does it come from?
  • Is the data diverse and fair, or could it lead to bias?
  • Does it comply with privacy laws?

• Stakeholder Impact:

  • Who will use the AI tool?
  • Will any groups be affected more than others?
  • How will users learn about the AI and give feedback if something goes wrong?

• Regulatory and Ethical Compliance:

  • What laws or industry standards apply?
  • How will you ensure the AI is transparent, accountable, and fair?
  • What steps can you take to prevent discrimination or misuse?

• •  

• Risk & Bias Mitigation:

  • What potential harms or unexpected results might occur?
  • Should there be human oversight for automated decisions?
  • What methods will you use to detect and correct biases during development?

• Stakeholder Consultation & Feedback:

  • How will you involve users, experts, and the community in your planning?
  • What is your process for gathering and responding to feedback?
  • How will you explain the AI’s decisions to people who aren’t technical experts?
  • Are there systems to audit and monitor the AI after it’s deployed?

Encouraging a Multidisciplinary Approach

Creating ethical AI isn’t just a job for coders. It’s important to work with experts from different fields:

• Ethicists help think about right and wrong.
• Legal Scholars explain the rules and regulations.
• Sociologists offer insights into how society is affected.

Group Activity:

• Form Teams: In a project, each student takes on a role, such as AI engineer, ethicist, policymaker, or sociologist.
• Define the Problem: Together, identify potential ethical issues in your AI project.
• Design Solutions: Propose ways to address these challenges—like changing data sources or adding human oversight.
• Present Your Findings: Share your plan with the class and explain how you considered different perspectives.

Example: How a School Can Adopt AI Responsibility

Imagine your school wants to create an AI tool that helps students pick extracurricular activities based on their interests. Before developing the system, your school could use the conceptualization phase to ensure it is ethical and fair.

1. Set Up a Multidisciplinary Team:

   • Include teachers, student representatives, and even parents. Each person takes on a role (e.g., technology expert, ethics advisor, communication officer).

2. Use a Pre-Development Checklist:

   • Data: Check that the data used (e.g., student surveys, past participation records) is diverse and accurate.
   • Impact: Consider which groups might be overlooked or unfairly treated by the recommendations.
   • Compliance: Ensure the system follows privacy rules and school policies.
   • Risk: Plan for human oversight—maybe a teacher reviews AI recommendations before final decisions are made.
   • Feedback: Set up a process where students can report if they feel the recommendations are biased or unfair.

3. Implement a Pilot Program:

   • Start with a small group of students. Let the team run the AI tool, gather feedback, and make improvements.
   • Hold a class discussion about the process and what was learned. For example, students might suggest more diverse data sources or additional checks before recommendations are finalized.

4. Final Decision and Monitoring:

   • After addressing feedback, launch the tool school-wide.
   • Continue to monitor its performance and hold regular review sessions to ensure it remains fair and effective.

Key Takeaways

• Plan Ahead: Use a checklist to think about data, impact, regulations, risks, and feedback before building an AI tool.
• Work Together: Bring in different experts (or roles) to look at the problem from multiple angles.
• Learn by Doing: Role-playing and team projects give you hands-on experience in ethical decision-making.
• Be Responsible: Adopting AI ethically means ensuring fairness, transparency, and accountability from the start.

By practicing these methods, you’ll be better prepared to design, evaluate, and improve AI systems—ensuring that technology works for everyone in a fair and responsible way.

0